Today's Feature Proposition C.
The Missouri Health Care
Freedom, Proposition C will appear on the August
3, 2010 statewide ballot in Missouri as an
legislatively-referred state statute. The
proposed measure aims to block the federal
government from requiring people to buy health
insurance and bans punishment for those without
health insurance.
Backers of such measures are
opposed to President Barack Obamas new
health care plans. The measure does not advocate
a particular plan but measure advocates say the
measure will "protect the individuals
right to make health care decisions."
Opponents of the measures and some constitutional
scholars say the proposals are mostly symbolic,
intended to send a message of political protest,
and have little chance of succeeding in court
over the long run.
On May 4, 2010 the Missouri
State Senate voted 26-8 in favor of referring the
proposed measure to the ballot. On May 11 the
House gave final approval to refer the measure to
the ballot following a 108-47 vote.
According to the Missouri
Secretary of State the official ballot title
reads as follows:
Official Ballot Title:
Shall the Missouri Statutes be
amended to:
* Deny the government authority
to penalize citizens for refusing to purchase
private health insurance or infringe upon the
right to offer or accept direct payment for
lawful healthcare services?
* Modify laws regarding the
liquidation of certain domestic insurance
companies?
It is estimated this proposal
will have no immediate costs or savings to state
or local governmental entities. However, because
of the uncertain interaction of the proposal with
implementation of the federal Patient Protection
and Affordable Care Act, future costs to state
governmental entities are unknown.
Fair Ballot Language: A
"yes" vote will amend Missouri law to
deny the government authority to penalize
citizens for refusing to purchase private health
insurance or infringe upon the right to offer or
accept direct payment for lawful healthcare
services. The amendment will also modify laws
regarding the liquidation of certain domestic
insurance companies.
A "no" vote will not
change the current Missouri law regarding private
health insurance, lawful healthcare services, and
the liquidation of certain domestic insurance
companies.
If passed, this measure will
have no impact on taxes.
Support
Sen. Jane Cunningham, a sponsor
of the proposed measure, argues that the measure
is about protecting personal liberties and
allowing Missouri residents to choose whether to
accept federal health care without any penalties.
"Missourians will lose absolutely nothing if
this amendment passes. They can choose the
government plan or they can choose anything else
they want," said Cunningham. But some
lawmakers argue that the health care legislation
crosses into states rights and oversteps
its own federal power. Sen. Jim Lembke
said,"If the federal government is going to
make all the decisions for us, why are we
here?"
In May 2010 media reports said
that local consultant Patrick Tuohey filed
paperwork to establish a committee in support of
the proposed health care freedom measure. The
official group in support of Proposition C is
Missourians for Health Care Freedom.
Donors
According to the quarterly
finance report filed July 15, Missourians for
Health Care Freedom received several donations
from June 18 through June 30. According to
reports, the group received $22,768.07 in
monetary contributions.[13] According to the
finance report, the group has had a total of
$9,700 in expenditures.[14]
Below is a chart that outlines
major cash contributions to Missourians for
Health Care Freedom:
Contributor Amount
Citizens for Brad Lager $5,000
Missourians for Goodman $5,000
Ray Vinson, Executive for
US Auto Protection $5,000
William Canfield, retired
$5,000
Fred Sauer, Orion
Investment Co. $5,000
Missourians for Mayer $2,500
Ron Richard 2010 $2,500
Opposition
Opponents argue that the
approved federal health care legislation is
similar to a mandate, requiring lawmakers to
cover treatment for autistic children - approved
in March 2010 by the Missouri State Senate. In
response to supporters arguments Sen.
Victor Callahan said,"Social Security per se
is not in the Constitution. I dont see it
in the Constitution but it appears to be on my
check every two weeks."
Opponents of the proposed
measure and supporters of the approved federal
health care reform created a group on Facebook
called "Vote No on Missouri Prop C."
The group, however, does not list an official
website. According to the groups logo, the
moto reads, "Protect Health Care For All
Missourians: No! on Prop C."
|