Today's
Feature
An Alternative
Suggestion.
Carthage City
Council agreed to look at the alternatives to a
rezoning request at Tuesdays meeting.
Council heard the
first reading of an ordinance requesting a zoning
change for property at 1926 and 1921 South
Garrison as proposed by Vince Scott, owner. The
zoning would change the buildings from Local
Business and First Dwelling House zoning to
General Business Zoning.
This item was
rejected by the Planning, Zoning and Historic
Preservation Committee after several citizens
spoke against it, but was appealed to Council.
The proposed zoning would allow sales of alcohol
by the drink.
City Administrator
Tom Short said that instead of a blanket rezoning
on the building at 1926 Garrison, there were
other options to achieve the results wished for
by the owner, simultaneously adding restrictions
for the sake of the neighbors.
According to Short
a Special Use Permit would be the best
alternative in that it would allow for alcohol
sales based on a percentage of food sales, it
could restrict hours of operation and could call
for review periods by Council at yearly
intervals. Short also said that unlike a rezoning
which is more permanent, the Special Use Permit
would be in effect as long as the function of the
building was the same, but would expire if the
function changed.
Council approved a
motion to draft an amendment to the City Code
adding a paragraph for Special Use Permits,
permitting alcohol sales based on a percentage of
food sales. The item was approved in a 7 to 3
vote. The drafting of the special use permit will
cause the item to be returned to the Planning and
Zoning Committee for further review and will
allow more time for citizen input.
Prior to the
reading of the ordinance and the development of
the proposed special use permit, several citizens
spoke in opposition to the rezoning. Citizen Ed
Browning spoke against the item saying that it
was not known what type of business would be
operated in the 1926 building. Browning said the
neighbors were not in favor of the presence of a
liquor store in the neighborhood and feared a
reduction of property value. According to a
showing of hands at meeting, there were over 12
citizens present who were opposed to the
rezoning.
Vince Scott, who
requested the rezoning, was also in attendance of
the meeting and asked Council to consider the
potential positive impacts of the rezoning. Scott
said he wants to open a restaurant with the
capability to sell wine in the 1926 building.
The Mornin
Mail archives have shown a similar case
reported in the September 23, 1998 edition of the
Mail. The Planning, Zoning and Historic
Preservation commission on Sept. 21, 1998 heard a
rezoning request for 1926 South Garrison which
would have changed the zoning from Local Business
zoning to General Business Zoning. At that time
the proposed use of the property was for an
outlet selling surplus/freight damaged
construction materials through the Tapjac
Company. Several neighboring property owners
attended the meeting to oppose the rezoning.
Citizens cited increased noise, increased traffic
and hours of operation as primary concerns. At
that time the item was not appealed to Council.
Just Like A
Play, Only Real.
Tuesdays
Council meeting was led by students from Carthage
City High School in conjunction with Student
Government Day. The list of students that
participated, and the City officials portrayed
included; Chase Pitner, Mayor Kenneth Johnson;
Madison McKnight, Fire Chief John Cooper; David
Martin, Public Works Director Chad Wampler;
Edmundo Fentanes, City Attorney David Mouton;
Carrie Spry, Police Chief Dennis Veach; Blair
Cummins, City Clerk Lynn Campbell; Matt Law,
CW&EP General Manager Bob Williams; Mallory
Goodman, Parks Director Alan Bull; Matt
Smallwood, Chamber of Commerce Director Max
McKnight.
Students and
Council members portrayed included: Lauren
Matthews, Claude Newport; Allee Shepherd, Larry
Ross; Emily Snyder, Mike Harris; Jessica Baugh,
Ron Wells; Stacey Chaney, Jackie Boyer; Kacie
Cooper, Diane Sharits; Josiah Coen, Bill Johnson;
Brynn Cummins, Bill Welch; Kate Kennedy, Tom
Flanigan; Meghan Waggoner, Jim Woestman.
The students sat
next to their respective Council members,
responded to council members names, read
staff reports and voted on ordinances.
Only a few times
did the arrangement prove to be complicated in
terms of Council members asking questions through
the students. Some Council members chose to
bypass the students and ask questions directly.
The students
approved a motion to offer support for the
Carthage R-9 bond proposition for the
construction of a new high school building,
approved an electric rate increase for Carthage
Water & Electric Plant and observed the
comments offered by citizens during the citizen
participation period.
When asked for
closing comments at the end of the meeting,
several students offered statements of
appreciation for the opportunity to experience
the inner workings of City government. Student
Josiah Coen described the joyful experience of
meeting City officials, visiting the Police
Station and Fire Department and serving as a
member of City Council as "nifty."
Student Government
Day is organized by the School and Fire Chief
John Cooper.
|